SaucyRossyBBQ KCBS Helper

← All events

Smoketoberfest 2019

Oct 4–5, 2019 · Ottumwa, IA · 📍 1 Joe Lord Memorial Dr. · State championship

Reps: Cindy Juhl, Tom Juhl · Prize money: $20,000

🥇
699.4172 · Master Series — Overall
🥈
698.8344 · Master Series — Overall
🥉
698.2744 · Master Series — Overall

ALL FORKED UP FOR Q won Grand Champion at the Smoketoberfest on October 4, 2019 in Ottumwa, IA at 1 Joe Lord Memorial Dr., scoring 699.4172 in a field of 49 teams. 2 CASE BBQ took Reserve Grand Champion with 698.8344. Category winners: Chicken — 2 CASE BBQ (180.0000); Pork Ribs — BOOM CHICKA COW COW (177.7372); Pork — UNFAMOUS DAVE'S (178.8572); Brisket — LUCKY'S Q (180.0000). This is the 2nd of 2 editions of this contest on record; the 2018 edition was won by A FINE SWINE.

The contest at a glance (read off the scored boards)

How the field scored

Overall totals, every team on the board — tall stacks are where the pack sat.

How the meats cooked

Every board on one scale — the bar runs last score to first, the dot is the median.

  • Chicken 180 🔥
  • Pork Ribs 177.74
  • Pork 178.86
  • Brisket 180 🔥
130.23 180

Entries

49
4 judged meats

Top score

699.4172

Winning margin

0.5828
GC over RC

Field average

658.96
571.84699.42
median 670.73 · last place to winner

Perfect 180s

3 🔥
LUCKY'S Q (Brisket), B-S BBQ OUTLAWS (Brisket), 2 CASE BBQ (Chicken)

Tightest race

Chicken
2.2972 pts across the top 5

Top-10 cutoff

689.0400
571.84699.42
10th place overall

Field spread

127.5772
winner to last place

Prize money

$20,000
on the line

Most consistent

avg finish 7 across 4 meats

Double threats

3
teams with 2+ top-5 calls

Widest winning margin

Pork Ribs
won by 2.8684 pts — BOOM CHICKA COW COW

How hot was the win?

Top 35%
beats 65% of 4711 Master Series wins in the data

Came back for more

35%
14 of 40 teams from the previous edition returned

Form held

Strong
ρ = -0.74 between pre-contest rating and finish

Field strength

1,591
avg power rating going in · stronger than 72% of contests

Top-rated in the field

rated 1974 pre-contest

Storylines (7 found in this contest's numbers)

Everything below is read straight out of the results — the number on each card is the one that made it a story.

A razor-thin finish

0.5828 points between champion and reserve

Closer than 89% of the 4,710 championships in the data

The Grand Championship was decided by 0.5828 points — closer than 89% of every championship in the data.

  • All Forked up for Q
  • 2 CASE BBQ

A new contest record

699.4172 highest overall ever cooked here

699.4172 is the highest overall score this contest has ever produced — past the 689.6456 A FINE SWINE set in 2018.

  • old record 689.6456
  • set 2018 by A FINE SWINE

An upset on the books

19-in-100 shot on pre-contest ratings

The ratings favoured the top seed the other 81 times in 100

ALL FORKED UP FOR Q came in rated below the field's top team, LUCKY'S Q, and took the Grand Championship anyway — roughly a 19-in-100 shot on pre-contest ratings.

  • champion 1716
  • top seed 1974

Won without a category win

4 of 4 meats called to the stage

ALL FORKED UP FOR Q won the Grand Championship without winning a single meat — 4 calls from 4 boards, best of them 3rd. Consistency beat fireworks.

  • Chicken 3rd
  • Pork Ribs 10th
  • Pork 9th
  • Brisket 6th

A day of perfect scores

3 perfect 180s

3 perfect 180s were scored at this contest — every judge at the table handing back a nine.

  • LUCKY'S Q · Brisket
  • B-S BBQ OUTLAWS · Brisket
  • 2 CASE BBQ · Chicken

Photo finishes

Tie closest of 13 calls decided inside half a point

Chicken places 3–4: ALL FORKED UP FOR Q and MEAT ME IN ST. LOUIS tied on 178.2972 — settled by the KCBS tiebreaker. Pork Ribs places 4–5: 2 CASE BBQ and Phoenix BBQ tied on 174.2972 — settled by the KCBS tiebreaker. Pork Ribs places 7–8: Chillin N Grillin N Iowa BBQ and THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE SMOKE tied on 174.2744 — settled by the KCBS tiebreaker.

  • Chicken 3–4 · tie
  • Pork Ribs 4–5 · tie
  • Pork Ribs 7–8 · tie
  • Pork Ribs 8–9 · tie

A contest record in pork ribs

177.7372 best pork ribs ever cooked here

BOOM CHICKA COW COW turned in 177.7372 in pork ribs — past the 173.1316 that had stood across 1 earlier editions.

  • old best 173.1316
  • across 1 past editions

Score curves (score by finishing position — steep cliffs mean a spread field, flat lines a knife fight)

Category showdown (top / average / median score per meat)

Biggest rating movers (power-rating points won and lost at this contest)

Did form hold? (pre-contest rating vs overall finish — ratings called it if the dots climb to the right)

This contest over the years full contest page →

DateWhereVenueTeamsHigh scoreGrand ChampionReserve Champion
Oct 5, 2018 Ottumwa, IA Jimmy Jones Shelter Park 40 689.6456 A FINE SWINE IOWA'S SMOKEY D'S BBQ
Oct 4, 2019 ← this one Ottumwa, IA 1 Joe Lord Memorial Dr. 49 699.4172 All Forked up for Q 2 CASE BBQ

What a call cost (the score it took to finish 1st, 5th and 10th)

Category1st5th10th
Chicken180177.7028174.2972
Pork Ribs177.7372174.2972173.7372
Pork178.8572172.5600170.3200
Brisket180176.5600174.8572

Official results on kcbs.us ↗

Master Series

Overall

49 entries · top 699.4172 · median 670.7312

#TeamScore
1 ALL FORKED UP FOR Q 699.4172
2 2 CASE BBQ 698.8344
3 HOGLINE 698.2744
4 B-S BBQ OUTLAWS 694.7884
5 UNFAMOUS DAVE'S 694.2744
6 Heavy Smoke BBQ 691.3600
7 LUCKY 19 SAUCE COMPANY 690.8344
8 THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE SMOKE 689.6800
9 Fat&Dumb BBQ 689.1084
10 MAN MEAT BBQ 689.0400
11 LUCKY'S Q 688.5140
12 HOT DADDY'S BBQ 686.1824
13 Bohica BBQ 683.9656
14 SmokinGhost BBQ 682.8572
15 SHIGGIN & GRINNIN 682.7772
16 Second String BBQ 680.4800
17 RUM N' SMOKE BBQ 679.3716
18 Luscious Loins 678.8228
19 BOOM CHICKA COW COW 678.7656
20 BAMBQ 677.7264
21 MEAT ME IN ST. LOUIS 672.5488
22 MAD MUTT'S BBQ 670.8460
23 Papa Linda's Barbecue 670.8120
24 GOTHIC TOWN GRILLERS 670.8000
25 Littles BBQ Co 670.7312
26 TREEFROG BBQ 669.1200
27 SMOKEHOUSE 72 667.9656
28 Phoenix BBQ 667.8972
29 DIABLOS BARBEQUE 658.2516
30 Chillin N Grillin N Iowa BBQ 656.4688
31 Eldon River BBQ 656.4344
32 TEAM CRAWFORD 651.9888
33 Smokin Double R BBQ 651.8856
34 R.C.BUCK'S GRILLIN' TEAM 650.7772
35 No Bull BBQ 645.0284
36 NA-DA-BONE BBQ 643.8284
37 T-Rex BBQ 643.3488
38 NEVER EASY BBQ 641.5656
39 DartyQ 623.9320
40 BBQCRITIC.COM 623.2912
41 American Piggers 619.9320
42 DGQ 617.6336
43 Pig Destroyer 615.8740
44 Five Hawgs BBQ 614.7200
45 Old Outlaw 612.5260
46 Masters BBQ 610.6972
47 JBS Pork-Ottumwa, IA 583.7940
48 Redneck BBQ 579.2348
49 Blowin Smoke BBQ 571.8400

Chicken

49 entries · top 180 · median 169.6912 · 🔥 perfect 180

#TeamScore
1 2 CASE BBQ 180 🔥
2 LUCKY 19 SAUCE COMPANY 178.3200
3 ALL FORKED UP FOR Q 178.2972
4 MEAT ME IN ST. LOUIS 178.2972
5 SmokinGhost BBQ 177.7028
6 Fat&Dumb BBQ 176.5600
7 RUM N' SMOKE BBQ 176.0116
8 TEAM CRAWFORD 175.4400
9 Bohica BBQ 174.8572
10 Second String BBQ 174.2972
11 B-S BBQ OUTLAWS 173.7028
12 Eldon River BBQ 173.1316
13 SHIGGIN & GRINNIN 173.1200
14 LUCKY'S Q 172.5600
15 DGQ 172.0228
16 HOGLINE 172
17 THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE SMOKE 170.8800
18 MAN MEAT BBQ 170.8228
19 Phoenix BBQ 170.8228
20 BAMBQ 170.2972
21 HOT DADDY'S BBQ 170.2744
22 SMOKEHOUSE 72 170.2628
23 UNFAMOUS DAVE'S 170.2628
24 NEVER EASY BBQ 169.7144
25 BOOM CHICKA COW COW 169.6912
26 Heavy Smoke BBQ 169.6684
27 Luscious Loins 168.5828
28 Littles BBQ Co 168.5256
29 DIABLOS BARBEQUE 166.2516
30 MAD MUTT'S BBQ 163.4172
31 DartyQ 163.4172
32 Papa Linda's Barbecue 162.8688
33 NA-DA-BONE BBQ 162.8228
34 No Bull BBQ 162.2628
35 Masters BBQ 161.7256
36 Chillin N Grillin N Iowa BBQ 161.1544
37 TREEFROG BBQ 161.1544
38 GOTHIC TOWN GRILLERS 159.9656
39 T-Rex BBQ 158.8572
40 Smokin Double R BBQ 155.4056
41 R.C.BUCK'S GRILLIN' TEAM 154.8116
42 BBQCRITIC.COM 154.2516
43 American Piggers 153.1316
44 Old Outlaw 150.8456
45 Pig Destroyer 150.8456
46 Blowin Smoke BBQ 143.3828
47 Redneck BBQ 141.6688
48 JBS Pork-Ottumwa, IA 141.6228
49 Five Hawgs BBQ 139.9200

Pork Ribs

49 entries · top 177.7372 · median 167.9772

#TeamScore
1 BOOM CHICKA COW COW 177.7372
2 BAMBQ 174.8688
3 Heavy Smoke BBQ 174.8572
4 2 CASE BBQ 174.2972
5 Phoenix BBQ 174.2972
6 Bohica BBQ 174.2856
7 Chillin N Grillin N Iowa BBQ 174.2744
8 THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE SMOKE 174.2744
9 MAN MEAT BBQ 174.2744
10 ALL FORKED UP FOR Q 173.7372
11 GOTHIC TOWN GRILLERS 173.1316
12 RUM N' SMOKE BBQ 173.1316
13 HOGLINE 173.1200
14 HOT DADDY'S BBQ 172.5484
15 SHIGGIN & GRINNIN 171.9772
16 MAD MUTT'S BBQ 171.4516
17 Luscious Loins 171.4172
18 MEAT ME IN ST. LOUIS 170.8916
19 Littles BBQ Co 170.8456
20 Second String BBQ 170.8344
21 Fat&Dumb BBQ 169.1312
22 LUCKY 19 SAUCE COMPANY 168.5372
23 UNFAMOUS DAVE'S 168.0116
24 Papa Linda's Barbecue 167.9772
25 B-S BBQ OUTLAWS 167.9772
26 Masters BBQ 166.8688
27 LUCKY'S Q 166.8456
28 TREEFROG BBQ 166.8456
29 SmokinGhost BBQ 165.7028
30 T-Rex BBQ 164.5488
31 BBQCRITIC.COM 163.9772
32 R.C.BUCK'S GRILLIN' TEAM 163.4400
33 SMOKEHOUSE 72 162.8800
34 Eldon River BBQ 162.8572
35 NEVER EASY BBQ 162.8340
36 DGQ 162.3200
37 NA-DA-BONE BBQ 162.2400
38 DIABLOS BARBEQUE 161.1200
39 TEAM CRAWFORD 160.5716
40 Smokin Double R BBQ 158.2400
41 DartyQ 156.5716
42 Redneck BBQ 156.5488
43 No Bull BBQ 154.7884
44 American Piggers 153.6688
45 Pig Destroyer 151.9772
46 JBS Pork-Ottumwa, IA 147.3600
47 Five Hawgs BBQ 145.7144
48 Old Outlaw 145.1200
49 Blowin Smoke BBQ 142.2400

Pork

49 entries · top 178.8572 · median 166.8688

#TeamScore
1 UNFAMOUS DAVE'S 178.8572
2 HOGLINE 178.2972
3 THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE SMOKE 174.2628
4 B-S BBQ OUTLAWS 173.1084
5 Fat&Dumb BBQ 172.5600
6 HOT DADDY'S BBQ 172.5484
7 Heavy Smoke BBQ 171.4172
8 SHIGGIN & GRINNIN 170.8456
9 ALL FORKED UP FOR Q 170.8228
10 DIABLOS BARBEQUE 170.3200
11 LUCKY 19 SAUCE COMPANY 170.2628
12 TEAM CRAWFORD 169.7372
13 R.C.BUCK'S GRILLIN' TEAM 169.6800
14 BOOM CHICKA COW COW 169.6800
15 MAN MEAT BBQ 169.6800
16 SmokinGhost BBQ 169.1772
17 Papa Linda's Barbecue 169.1316
18 LUCKY'S Q 169.1084
19 No Bull BBQ 168.5372
20 2 CASE BBQ 167.9772
21 Second String BBQ 167.9656
22 GOTHIC TOWN GRILLERS 167.4400
23 MEAT ME IN ST. LOUIS 167.4172
24 Chillin N Grillin N Iowa BBQ 167.3828
25 BAMBQ 166.8688
26 DartyQ 165.7028
27 Smokin Double R BBQ 165.6800
28 RUM N' SMOKE BBQ 165.1428
29 TREEFROG BBQ 165.1200
30 Luscious Loins 164.5600
31 Phoenix BBQ 163.9772
32 Five Hawgs BBQ 163.9656
33 Eldon River BBQ 163.3828
34 Pig Destroyer 163.3828
35 SMOKEHOUSE 72 162.8572
36 American Piggers 161.1428
37 MAD MUTT'S BBQ 159.9772
38 Old Outlaw 159.4172
39 T-Rex BBQ 159.4172
40 Littles BBQ Co 159.3944
41 NEVER EASY BBQ 158.8228
42 NA-DA-BONE BBQ 157.6684
43 BBQCRITIC.COM 156.5484
44 Blowin Smoke BBQ 155.9544
45 Bohica BBQ 155.3828
46 JBS Pork-Ottumwa, IA 151.9884
47 Redneck BBQ 150.7884
48 Masters BBQ 146.1944
49 DGQ 133.0280

Brisket

49 entries · top 180 · median 165.6916 · 🔥 perfect 180

#TeamScore
1 LUCKY'S Q 180 🔥
2 B-S BBQ OUTLAWS 180 🔥
3 Bohica BBQ 179.4400
4 UNFAMOUS DAVE'S 177.1428
5 2 CASE BBQ 176.5600
6 ALL FORKED UP FOR Q 176.5600
7 MAD MUTT'S BBQ 176
8 TREEFROG BBQ 176
9 Heavy Smoke BBQ 175.4172
10 HOGLINE 174.8572
11 Luscious Loins 174.2628
12 MAN MEAT BBQ 174.2628
13 LUCKY 19 SAUCE COMPANY 173.7144
14 Smokin Double R BBQ 172.5600
15 SMOKEHOUSE 72 171.9656
16 Littles BBQ Co 171.9656
17 Fat&Dumb BBQ 170.8572
18 Papa Linda's Barbecue 170.8344
19 HOT DADDY'S BBQ 170.8112
20 SmokinGhost BBQ 170.2744
21 THERE'S NO PLACE LIKE SMOKE 170.2628
22 GOTHIC TOWN GRILLERS 170.2628
23 Second String BBQ 167.3828
24 SHIGGIN & GRINNIN 166.8344
25 BAMBQ 165.6916
26 Five Hawgs BBQ 165.1200
27 RUM N' SMOKE BBQ 165.0856
28 R.C.BUCK'S GRILLIN' TEAM 162.8456
29 BOOM CHICKA COW COW 161.6572
30 NA-DA-BONE BBQ 161.0972
31 DIABLOS BARBEQUE 160.5600
32 T-Rex BBQ 160.5256
33 No Bull BBQ 159.4400
34 Phoenix BBQ 158.8000
35 Old Outlaw 157.1432
36 Eldon River BBQ 157.0628
37 MEAT ME IN ST. LOUIS 155.9428
38 Chillin N Grillin N Iowa BBQ 153.6572
39 American Piggers 151.9888
40 DGQ 150.2628
41 NEVER EASY BBQ 150.1944
42 Pig Destroyer 149.6684
43 BBQCRITIC.COM 148.5140
44 TEAM CRAWFORD 146.2400
45 JBS Pork-Ottumwa, IA 142.8228
46 DartyQ 138.2404
47 Masters BBQ 135.9084
48 Blowin Smoke BBQ 130.2628
49 Redneck BBQ 130.2288

Heading out? 🔥

Are you sure you want to leave the KCBS Helper Tool and go to SaucyRossyBBQ.com?

Yes, take me there

Hey, I’m Ross

Most folks know me as SaucyRossyBBQ. I built this Helper App myself and put it out for free, because I wanted the tool to exist for our sport — no paywall, no account needed.

If you’ve got it in you to chip in, it means a whole lot. And if you’ve already bought me a coffee — thank you so much. Your support pays the server and hosting bills that keep a system like this running.

Buy me a coffee

You won’t see this again for a month. Now get back to it — good luck at your next cook. 🔥