The biggest — and smallest — numbers anybody has ever put in front of six judges.
705.7144
Master Series, out of 720
🤝
YELLOW RIVER BBQ at PigMania Lima
May 29, 2015
27-team field · won the contest
Held jointly by 2 — nobody has beaten it.
Four meats, six judges, one afternoon. The biggest total anybody has ever assembled.
- =1LOCAL YOKELS BBQ705.7144
- 3CHUNKY BBQ705.6800
- 4CHIX, SWINE & BOVINE BBQ705.1544
The full top 10 →
346.9032
Backyard Series, out of 360
🥇
Full Throttle BBQ at Marietta River City BBQ
Apr 23, 2021
won the board
The Backyard board runs on its own scale, so it keeps its own record — pooled with Master it would never surface at all.
- 2D’Qued Barbeque328.5484
- 3Ham Squad313.6912
- 4Dogpatch Q307.9428
The full top 8 →
180
one meat, out of 180
🤝
BIG JT'S SMOKIN BBQ at The River Grill before the Big Chill
Oct 10, 2014
won the category with it
Held jointly by 10 or more — nobody has beaten it.
The best chicken anybody has ever turned in. 180 is the ceiling — every judge at the table handing back a nine — so a tie goes to whoever got there first.
- =1SLIPPERY PETE'S BBQ180
- =12 WORTHLESS NUTS, NATURAL BORN GRILLERS180
- =1BRUTUS AND COMPANY180
The full top 10 →
180
one meat, out of 180
🤝
BARK BROTHERS BBQ at The River Grill before the Big Chill
Oct 10, 2014
won the category with it
Held jointly by 4 — nobody has beaten it.
The best pork ribs anybody has ever turned in. 180 is the ceiling — every judge at the table handing back a nine — so a tie goes to whoever got there first.
- =1VICTORY SMOKERS180
- =1BO B Q BBQ180
- =1TIRE SMOKE BBQ180
The full top 10 →
180
one meat, out of 180
🤝
HOOSIER FAVORITE BBQ at Ohio Veteran Battle of the Barbecue
Sep 27, 2013
won the category with it
Held jointly by 10 or more — nobody has beaten it.
The best pork anybody has ever turned in. 180 is the ceiling — every judge at the table handing back a nine — so a tie goes to whoever got there first.
- =1YELLOW RIVER BBQ180
- =1FARMER'S RETREAT SMOKIN BARBEQUE180
- =1THUNDER HOG BBQ180
The full top 10 →
180
one meat, out of 180
🤝
CHARCOAL MAFIA at The River Grill before the Big Chill
Oct 10, 2014
won the category with it
Held jointly by 10 or more — nobody has beaten it.
The best brisket anybody has ever turned in. 180 is the ceiling — every judge at the table handing back a nine — so a tie goes to whoever got there first.
- =1DINO BONER BBQ180
- =1Extra Mile BBQ180
- =1Smitty's Real Pit BBQ180
The full top 10 →
703.3944
Master Series, out of 720
🥇
BIG JT'S SMOKIN BBQ at The River Grill before the Big Chill
Oct 10, 2014
finished 2nd, behind Bubba Grills
A day this good takes a Grand Championship almost anywhere. These are the ones that ran into somebody having a better one.
- 2Extra Mile BBQ702.2400
- 3THE AMERICAN DREAM BBQ701.6572
- 4SMOKE-N-PEPPERS701.1544
The full top 10 →
678.8572
Master Series, out of 720
🥇
MONTY PIGTHON & THE HOLY GRILL at Buckeye State BBQ Championship
May 17, 2013
and still beat 34 other teams
The days the judges gave nothing away. Somebody still had to win, and this is the smallest number that ever did it in a real field.
- 2ABLE ACRES BBQ683.4172
- 3BRISKETS-BONES & BREWS BBQ684.5144
- 4PARROTHEAD SMOKERS684.5600
The full top 10 →
689.6568
the score 10th overall took
🥇
Grizzly BBQ Brawl
Sep 5, 2025
42 teams · won with 702.8228
What it cost to walk. At these contests a total that wins most weekends was only good enough for tenth.
- 2Buckeye BBQ Classic689.6340
- 3The River Grill before the Big Chill687.4172
- 4Ohio Smoked Meat & BBQ Festival687.3484
The full top 10 →
676.93
average Master overall score
🥇
Buckeye BBQ Classic
Jul 17, 2026
30 teams · top score 700.5944
Judging tables are not interchangeable. At these contests the whole field scored high — not just the winner.
- 2BLACK BOX BBQ @ Wadsworth Municipal Airport674.21
- 3Destination Outlets Labor Day BBQ Championship669.26
- 4PigMania Lebanon State Championship BBQ & Music Festival669.19
The full top 10 →
628.41
average Master overall score
🥇
Smokin' in the Hills
Sep 24, 2021
26 teams · even the win only took 705.7144
The other end of the same measurement: the contests where hardly anybody got a good card all day.
- 2Marietta River City BBQ634.61
- 3Buckeye State BBQ Championship636.49
- 4Holy Smokes BBQ Competition642.44
The full top 10 →
684.29
average Master overall, out of 720
🥇
SLIPPERY PETE'S BBQ
Oct 18, 2019
28 contests · best 705.1432
Anyone can catch one good day. This is the highest anybody has averaged across a real career.
- 2TIRE SMOKE BBQ682.55
- 3SMOKIN' 4-PLAY BBQ675.72
- 4ELEGANTLY VIOLENT BBQ674.90
The full top 10 →
15.4976
points clear of the runner-up
🥇
CHIX, SWINE & BOVINE BBQ at Ohio Smoked Meat & BBQ Festival
Oct 17, 2014
over HISTORIC BBQ
Not a contest so much as an exhibition — the runner-up in each of these was closer to tenth than to the winner.
- 2BLUE CHIP BBQ13.1884
- 3CONTAGIOUS Q13.1540
- 4LOCAL YOKELS BBQ13.1312
The full top 10 →
0.0116
points between champion and reserve
🥇
ABLE ACRES BBQ at Buckeye State BBQ Championship
May 16, 2014
over Pappy Q
A whole weekend — four meats, twenty-four judging cards — decided by a rounding error.
- 2HOOSIER FAVORITE BBQ0.0460
- 3TIRE SMOKE BBQ0.0804
- 4ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN0.4912
The full top 10 →