SaucyRossyBBQ KCBS Helper

← All events

Cotton Pickin BBQ Cook-Off

2016-07-29 – 2016-07-30 · Hartselle, AL · 📍 Hartselle, AL

Grand Champion: HICKORY PRIME (703.9544) · 33 teams

Reserve Champion: 🥈 Organizer Portal

🥇
703.9544 · Master Series — Overall
🥈
701.1084 · Master Series — Overall
🥉
699.3828 · Master Series — Overall

The contest at a glance (read off the scored boards)

How the field scored

Overall totals, every team on the board — tall stacks are where the pack sat.

How the meats cooked

Every board on one scale — the bar runs last score to first, the dot is the median.

  • Chicken 178.86
  • Pork Ribs 180.00 🔥
  • Pork 180.00 🔥
  • Brisket 178.86
150.22 180.00

Winning score by edition

What it has taken to win here, 2013 to 2019 — this edition picked out.

2013-05-17 — 699.4284 (JIGGY PIGGY) 2016-07-29 — 703.9544 (HICKORY PRIME) 2017-07-28 — 694.8340 (SMOKE ME SILLY) 2018-07-27 — 694.8340 (SMOKE ME SILLY) 2019-07-26 — 691.9312 (Fat, Drunk, & Stupid) 703.95 2013 2019

Entries

33
4 judged meats · 6 ancillary

Top score

703.9544

Winning margin

2.8460
GC over RC

Field average

675.20
647.18703.95
median 674.16 · last place to winner

Perfect 180s

2 🔥

Tightest race

Chicken
3.4400 pts across the top 5

Top-10 cutoff

687.9200
647.18703.95
10th place overall

Field spread

56.7780
winner to last place

Most consistent

avg finish 5.00 across 4 meats

Double threats

4
teams with 2+ top-5 calls

Widest winning margin

Brisket
won by 2.2972 pts — SOUTH PORK

How hot was the win?

Top 18%
beats 82% of 4707 Master Series wins in the data

Came back for more

33%
9 of 27 teams from the previous edition returned

Form held

Strong
ρ = -0.75 between pre-contest rating and finish

Field strength

1602
avg power rating going in · stronger than 79% of contests

Top-rated in the field

rated 1882 pre-contest

Storylines (9 found in this contest's numbers)

Everything below is read straight out of the results — the number on each card is the one that made it a story.

A new contest record

703.9544 highest overall ever cooked here

703.9544 is the highest overall score this contest has ever produced — past the 699.4284 JIGGY PIGGY set in 2013.

  • old record 699.4284
  • set 2013 by JIGGY PIGGY

An upset on the books

30-in-100 shot on pre-contest ratings

The ratings favoured the top seed the other 70 times in 100

HICKORY PRIME came in rated below the field's top team, Organizer Portal, and took the Grand Championship anyway — roughly a 30-in-100 shot on pre-contest ratings.

  • champion 1736
  • top seed 1882

A dynasty in the making

wins at this contest

2 of 5 tracked editions

SMOKE ME SILLY has won this contest 2 times across its 5 tracked editions.

  • 2017
  • 2018

Photo finishes

Tie closest of 11 calls decided inside half a point

Pork Ribs places 4–5: Organizer Portal and THE PIT CREW GA tied on 176.5600 — settled by the KCBS tiebreaker. Pork Ribs places 8–9: BREWS & QUE and SMOKE ON THIS tied on 174.2744 — settled by the KCBS tiebreaker. Pork places 6–7: BIG G BBQ and THE PIT CREW GA tied on 174.8572 — settled by the KCBS tiebreaker.

  • Pork Ribs 4–5 · tie
  • Pork Ribs 8–9 · tie
  • Pork 6–7 · tie
  • Brisket 2–3 · tie

How the title was won

3 of 4 meats called to the stage

HICKORY PRIME took the title on 3 calls from 4 meats, with 1 outright win — their weakest board was pork ribs at 11th.

  • Chicken 6th
  • Pork Ribs 11th
  • Pork 1st
  • Brisket 2nd

A contest record in pork ribs

180.0000 best pork ribs ever cooked here

ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN turned in 180.0000 in pork ribs — past the 176.5714 that had stood across 1 earlier editions.

  • old best 176.5714
  • across 1 past editions

Back to defend

1 past champions back in the field

Past winners of this contest cooked this edition: JIGGY PIGGY (won 2013).

  • JIGGY PIGGY · 2013

The contest returns

3.2 yrs since the last edition

This contest was away for 3.2 years — the previous tracked edition ran on 2013-05-17.

  • previous edition 2013-05-17

A perfect score on the table

2 perfect 180s

2 perfect 180s were scored at this contest — every judge at the table handing back a nine.

  • HICKORY PRIME · Pork
  • ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN · Pork Ribs

Score curves (score by finishing position — steep cliffs mean a spread field, flat lines a knife fight)

Category showdown (top / average / median score per meat)

Biggest rating movers (power-rating points won and lost at this contest)

Did form hold? (pre-contest rating vs overall finish — ratings called it if the dots climb to the right)

This contest over the years full contest page →

DateWhereVenueTeamsHigh scoreGrand ChampionReserve Champion
2013-05-17 Hartselle, AL Hartselle, AL 27 699.4284 JIGGY PIGGY THE LOONEY PIT
2016-07-29 ← this one Hartselle, AL Hartselle, AL 33 703.9544 HICKORY PRIME Organizer Portal
2017-07-28 Hartselle, AL 110 Railroad Street 27 694.8340 SMOKE ME SILLY HOT WACHULA'S
2018-07-27 Hartselle, AL 110 Railroad Street 27 694.8340 SMOKE ME SILLY HOT WACHULA'S
2019-07-26 Hartselle, AL Nanceford Rd 27 691.9312 Fat, Drunk, & Stupid HOT WACHULA'S
2020-07-24 Hartselle, AL

What a call cost (the score it took to finish 1st, 5th and 10th)

Category1st5th10th
Chicken178.8572175.4172173.1200
Pork Ribs180.0000176.5600174.2628
Pork180.0000175.4516171.9884
Brisket178.8572175.4172172.5600

Official results on kcbs.us ↗

Master Series

Overall

33 entries · top 703.9544 · median 674.1600

#TeamScore
1 HICKORY PRIME 703.9544
2 Organizer Portal 701.1084
3 ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN 699.3828
4 JIGGY PIGGY 694.2284
5 THE SPECIALISTS 692.5256
6 SMOKE ON THIS 692.5256
7 SOUTH PORK 690.8000
8 HOT COLE'S BBQ 690.2056
9 RED EYED SMOKERS 688.4684
10 THE PIT CREW GA 687.9200
11 BAYOU BOOGIE BBQ 684.4684
12 BEES KNEES BBQ TEAM 683.4060
13 BREWS & QUE 683.3256
14 NEW SOUTH BBQ 682.2516
15 BUSH LEAGUE BBQ 681.1312
16 GRILL DOCTOR'S 678.7428
17 STARS AND BARS BBQ 674.1600
18 SMOKIN' F BBQ 673.6000
19 SWINE AND SHINE BBQ 670.7544
20 JOBEAZ BLAZIN' BUTTS AND WINGS 668.4684
21 PAPA'S SMOKE PIT 666.7884
22 BUCKSHOT MALONE'S PIG SHACK 666.7544
23 BIG G BBQ 666.1596
24 WAY 2 QUE 664.4456
25 SOUTHERN SWINE 662.7200
26 SMOKIN BUTT CREW 662.6744
27 FAT, DRUNK & STUPID 657.5312
28 CRIMSON Q 656.9828
29 T & J's Dirty Butts 654.7200
30 Hogwash 653.5428
31 SMOKE-N-ASHES 650.6972
32 The Lumbee Smokers 650.1372
33 SMOKE OF THE SHOALS 647.1764

Chicken

33 entries · top 178.8572 · median 169.7144

#TeamScore
1 Organizer Portal 178.8572
2 BREWS & QUE 177.7144
3 ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN 177.1428
4 SMOKE ON THIS 175.4400
5 THE SPECIALISTS 175.4172
6 HICKORY PRIME 175.4056
7 THE PIT CREW GA 174.8456
8 NEW SOUTH BBQ 174.2744
9 JIGGY PIGGY 173.7028
10 SMOKE-N-ASHES 173.1200
11 FAT, DRUNK & STUPID 173.1084
12 PAPA'S SMOKE PIT 172.5828
13 SOUTH PORK 172.5828
14 RED EYED SMOKERS 172.5600
15 SOUTHERN SWINE 170.8456
16 BAYOU BOOGIE BBQ 170.8228
17 JOBEAZ BLAZIN' BUTTS AND WINGS 169.7144
18 SMOKIN' F BBQ 169.6800
19 BUSH LEAGUE BBQ 169.1656
20 HOT COLE'S BBQ 169.1200
21 BEES KNEES BBQ TEAM 168.5716
22 CRIMSON Q 167.9772
23 STARS AND BARS BBQ 167.3712
24 GRILL DOCTOR'S 165.6800
25 Hogwash 164.5488
26 SWINE AND SHINE BBQ 164.5256
27 BIG G BBQ 163.9312
28 SMOKE OF THE SHOALS 162.7768
29 The Lumbee Smokers 162.2628
30 WAY 2 QUE 162.2284
31 T & J's Dirty Butts 161.6800
32 SMOKIN BUTT CREW 160.5144
33 BUCKSHOT MALONE'S PIG SHACK 158.8228

Pork Ribs

33 entries · top 180.0000 · median 168.5256 · 🔥 perfect 180

#TeamScore
1 ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN 180.0000 🔥
2 HOT COLE'S BBQ 177.7144
3 JIGGY PIGGY 176.5944
4 Organizer Portal 176.5600
5 THE PIT CREW GA 176.5600
6 WAY 2 QUE 176.0000
7 THE SPECIALISTS 174.8572
8 BREWS & QUE 174.2744
9 SMOKE ON THIS 174.2744
10 BAYOU BOOGIE BBQ 174.2628
11 HICKORY PRIME 171.9888
12 JOBEAZ BLAZIN' BUTTS AND WINGS 171.4056
13 NEW SOUTH BBQ 170.8228
14 RED EYED SMOKERS 170.8228
15 BUCKSHOT MALONE'S PIG SHACK 168.5372
16 SMOKIN' F BBQ 168.5372
17 GRILL DOCTOR'S 168.5256
18 SOUTH PORK 167.3944
19 SWINE AND SHINE BBQ 166.8572
20 BEES KNEES BBQ TEAM 166.8344
21 CRIMSON Q 166.2860
22 BUSH LEAGUE BBQ 165.6916
23 BIG G BBQ 165.6684
24 The Lumbee Smokers 164.5372
25 FAT, DRUNK & STUPID 163.9656
26 Hogwash 163.9544
27 PAPA'S SMOKE PIT 163.3828
28 SMOKIN BUTT CREW 162.8000
29 T & J's Dirty Butts 162.8000
30 STARS AND BARS BBQ 162.8000
31 SMOKE OF THE SHOALS 162.7884
32 SMOKE-N-ASHES 160.5256
33 SOUTHERN SWINE 159.9544

Pork

33 entries · top 180.0000 · median 169.6800 · 🔥 perfect 180

#TeamScore
1 HICKORY PRIME 180.0000 🔥
2 BEES KNEES BBQ TEAM 177.7372
3 BUCKSHOT MALONE'S PIG SHACK 177.7144
4 BUSH LEAGUE BBQ 177.1428
5 STARS AND BARS BBQ 175.4516
6 BIG G BBQ 174.8572
7 THE PIT CREW GA 174.8572
8 NEW SOUTH BBQ 173.1428
9 The Lumbee Smokers 173.1200
10 Organizer Portal 171.9884
11 SOUTH PORK 171.9656
12 RED EYED SMOKERS 170.8228
13 HOT COLE'S BBQ 170.8112
14 SMOKE ON THIS 170.2512
15 PAPA'S SMOKE PIT 169.7256
16 WAY 2 QUE 169.7028
17 SWINE AND SHINE BBQ 169.6800
18 BAYOU BOOGIE BBQ 169.1200
19 GRILL DOCTOR'S 169.1200
20 JIGGY PIGGY 168.5256
21 SMOKIN' F BBQ 167.9656
22 JOBEAZ BLAZIN' BUTTS AND WINGS 166.8228
23 THE SPECIALISTS 166.2512
24 SMOKIN BUTT CREW 166.2400
25 ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN 165.6800
26 T & J's Dirty Butts 164.5600
27 FAT, DRUNK & STUPID 164.5372
28 SOUTHERN SWINE 163.9428
29 SMOKE-N-ASHES 163.4172
30 BREWS & QUE 163.3712
31 SMOKE OF THE SHOALS 161.6456
32 Hogwash 159.9540
33 CRIMSON Q 158.1940

Brisket

33 entries · top 178.8572 · median 167.9772

#TeamScore
1 SOUTH PORK 178.8572
2 HICKORY PRIME 176.5600
3 ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN 176.5600
4 THE SPECIALISTS 176.0000
5 GRILL DOCTOR'S 175.4172
6 JIGGY PIGGY 175.4056
7 RED EYED SMOKERS 174.2628
8 Organizer Portal 173.7028
9 SMOKIN BUTT CREW 173.1200
10 HOT COLE'S BBQ 172.5600
11 SMOKE ON THIS 172.5600
12 BEES KNEES BBQ TEAM 170.2628
13 BAYOU BOOGIE BBQ 170.2628
14 SWINE AND SHINE BBQ 169.6916
15 BUSH LEAGUE BBQ 169.1312
16 STARS AND BARS BBQ 168.5372
17 SOUTHERN SWINE 167.9772
18 BREWS & QUE 167.9656
19 SMOKIN' F BBQ 167.4172
20 T & J's Dirty Butts 165.6800
21 Hogwash 165.0856
22 CRIMSON Q 164.5256
23 NEW SOUTH BBQ 164.0116
24 BIG G BBQ 161.7028
25 BUCKSHOT MALONE'S PIG SHACK 161.6800
26 THE PIT CREW GA 161.6572
27 PAPA'S SMOKE PIT 161.0972
28 JOBEAZ BLAZIN' BUTTS AND WINGS 160.5256
29 SMOKE OF THE SHOALS 159.9656
30 WAY 2 QUE 156.5144
31 FAT, DRUNK & STUPID 155.9200
32 SMOKE-N-ASHES 153.6344
33 The Lumbee Smokers 150.2172

Ancillary categories

Run by the organizers alongside the sanctioned contest. These are judged on their own terms and do not count toward the overall score, so they're kept out of the meat stats above.

Master Series — Backyard Championship

27 entries · top 342.2512 · median 332.5260

#TeamScore
1 SOUTH RYLAND 342.2512
2 THIN BLUE SWINE BBQ 341.6688
3 LEE LA Q 341.1200
4 The 4th Little Pig 341.0972
5 BEER PRESSURE 338.8112
6 ALL SMOKED UP 338.2172
7 DANG GOOD BBQ 337.6800
8 HELL ON SQUEALS 336.5372
9 SHEATS SMOKED MEATS 335.9540
10 Mac Attack 335.3600
11 A VIEW TO A GRILL 334.8572
12 Slingin Pig Meat 334.2056
13 PIT ROW BBQ 333.6228
14 THE FAT GUYZ 332.5260
15 Cala-Bama Q 332.4800
16 Heavy P BBQ 331.9772
17 SMOKIN A FATTY 329.6228
18 SMOKIN' HOT ASHES 323.3256
19 BONNIE BLUE BBQ 319.3944
20 Lenox and Son BBQ Company 319.3828
21 Barrel of Laughs 318.7884
22 Butts & Babes 318.7772
23 GOOD 'N SAUCED 317.6684
24 Gustoso BBQ 313.1088
25 Hartwood BBQ 312.5144
26 MURPHY'S BACKYARD BBQ 309.6344
27 RIB TICKLERS 302.2516

Master Series — Backyard Chicken

27 entries · top 177.7028 · median 168.5256

#TeamScore
1 SOUTH RYLAND 177.7028
2 The 4th Little Pig 175.4172
3 Mac Attack 175.4056
4 LEE LA Q 173.1200
5 SMOKIN A FATTY 170.8344
6 ALL SMOKED UP 170.8228
7 Slingin Pig Meat 170.8228
8 DANG GOOD BBQ 170.2744
9 THIN BLUE SWINE BBQ 169.6800
10 Lenox and Son BBQ Company 169.1312
11 SHEATS SMOKED MEATS 169.1084
12 Heavy P BBQ 168.5600
13 BEER PRESSURE 168.5256
14 PIT ROW BBQ 168.5256
15 BONNIE BLUE BBQ 167.4172
16 HELL ON SQUEALS 167.4056
17 Cala-Bama Q 165.0972
18 Hartwood BBQ 164.5372
19 THE FAT GUYZ 163.3944
20 A VIEW TO A GRILL 162.8572
21 GOOD 'N SAUCED 160.5256
22 SMOKIN' HOT ASHES 160.5140
23 Butts & Babes 159.9772
24 Barrel of Laughs 159.9312
25 Gustoso BBQ 157.1200
26 MURPHY'S BACKYARD BBQ 151.9200
27 RIB TICKLERS 150.8572

Master Series — Backyard Pork

27 entries · top 177.1544 · median 166.2400

#TeamScore
1 BEER PRESSURE 177.1544
2 HELL ON SQUEALS 175.4172
3 Mac Attack 175.4172
4 PIT ROW BBQ 174.2628
5 The 4th Little Pig 170.8344
6 THE FAT GUYZ 169.6916
7 Cala-Bama Q 169.6684
8 Butts & Babes 169.1084
9 THIN BLUE SWINE BBQ 168.5256
10 DANG GOOD BBQ 167.9772
11 A VIEW TO A GRILL 167.4172
12 SOUTH RYLAND 167.4056
13 Heavy P BBQ 167.3828
14 Barrel of Laughs 166.2400
15 Slingin Pig Meat 165.6916
16 LEE LA Q 164.5372
17 SMOKIN A FATTY 163.9656
18 RIB TICKLERS 163.9544
19 ALL SMOKED UP 162.8000
20 MURPHY'S BACKYARD BBQ 161.0856
21 SMOKIN' HOT ASHES 161.0856
22 Lenox and Son BBQ Company 153.6112
23 Hartwood BBQ 153.0628
24 Gustoso BBQ 150.1828
25 BONNIE BLUE BBQ 150.1828
26 SHEATS SMOKED MEATS 150.1712
27 GOOD 'N SAUCED 148.4800

Master Series — Backyard Ribs

27 entries · top 172.0000 · median 163.4172

#TeamScore
1 A VIEW TO A GRILL 172.0000
2 THIN BLUE SWINE BBQ 171.9888
3 BEER PRESSURE 170.2856
4 THE FAT GUYZ 169.1316
5 HELL ON SQUEALS 169.1316
6 LEE LA Q 168.0000
7 DANG GOOD BBQ 167.4056
8 ALL SMOKED UP 167.3944
9 Cala-Bama Q 167.3828
10 SHEATS SMOKED MEATS 166.8456
11 The 4th Little Pig 165.6800
12 PIT ROW BBQ 165.0972
13 SOUTH RYLAND 164.5484
14 Heavy P BBQ 163.4172
15 Slingin Pig Meat 163.3828
16 SMOKIN' HOT ASHES 162.8116
17 Mac Attack 159.9544
18 Barrel of Laughs 158.8572
19 Butts & Babes 158.8000
20 SMOKIN A FATTY 158.7884
21 MURPHY'S BACKYARD BBQ 157.7144
22 GOOD 'N SAUCED 157.1428
23 Gustoso BBQ 155.9888
24 BONNIE BLUE BBQ 151.9772
25 RIB TICKLERS 151.3944
26 Lenox and Son BBQ Company 150.2516
27 Hartwood BBQ 147.9772

Master Series — Dessert

22 entries · top 180.0000 · median 170.8744 · 🔥 perfect 180

#TeamScore
1 THE FAT GUYZ 180.0000 🔥
2 THIN BLUE SWINE BBQ 178.8800
3 SOUTH PORK 177.7028
4 Slingin Pig Meat 176.5600
5 SMOKIN BUTT CREW 176.0000
6 CRIMSON Q 174.8800
7 ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN 173.7028
8 Butts & Babes 173.1428
9 SMOKIN' F BBQ 173.1200
10 HELL ON SQUEALS 172.0800
11 Hogwash 172.0344
12 NEW SOUTH BBQ 169.7144
13 SOUTH RYLAND 169.6684
14 The Lumbee Smokers 169.2116
15 ALL SMOKED UP 169.1200
16 STARS AND BARS BBQ 166.3200
17 RIB TICKLERS 166.2628
18 SMOKE-N-ASHES 166.2512
19 BREWS & QUE 158.8572
20 Hartwood BBQ 155.3712
21 BONNIE BLUE BBQ 153.6916
22 MURPHY'S BACKYARD BBQ 150.8000

Master Series — Sauce

29 entries · top 177.7144 · median 166.2512

#TeamScore
1 BONNIE BLUE BBQ 177.7144
2 BEER PRESSURE 173.1544
3 Mac Attack 171.9884
4 ROOTERS-N-TOOTERS TN 171.4284
5 RIB TICKLERS 171.4056
6 HOT COLE'S BBQ 170.8456
7 Heavy P BBQ 170.8456
8 HELL ON SQUEALS 169.6684
9 SMOKIN' F BBQ 168.5828
10 BEES KNEES BBQ TEAM 168.0000
11 LEE LA Q 167.9656
12 SMOKIN BUTT CREW 167.9656
13 SHEATS SMOKED MEATS 167.4056
14 HICKORY PRIME 167.3712
15 Lenox and Son BBQ Company 166.2512
16 Slingin Pig Meat 165.7028
17 Hartwood BBQ 165.1084
18 The Lumbee Smokers 165.0740
19 SMOKE-N-ASHES 164.5140
20 THIN BLUE SWINE BBQ 163.4056
21 Hogwash 163.3828
22 MURPHY'S BACKYARD BBQ 163.3828
23 THE SPECIALISTS 162.2856
24 Butts & Babes 161.7372
25 THE FAT GUYZ 161.6340
26 SOUTH PORK 161.1084
27 BIG G BBQ 161.0856
28 STARS AND BARS BBQ 156.5600
29 ALL SMOKED UP 155.4516

Heading out? 🔥

Are you sure you want to leave the KCBS Helper Tool and go to SaucyRossyBBQ.com?

Yes, take me there

Hey, I’m Ross

Most folks know me as SaucyRossyBBQ. I built this Helper App myself and put it out for free, because I wanted the tool to exist for our sport — no paywall, no account needed.

If you’ve got it in you to chip in, it means a whole lot. And if you’ve already bought me a coffee — thank you so much. Your support pays the server and hosting bills that keep a system like this running.

Buy me a coffee

You won’t see this again for a month. Now get back to it — good luck at your next cook. 🔥