Head-to-head
Pine Tar BBQ vs MAD MUTT'S BBQ
2 head-to-head wins
Met
25 times in the data
23 head-to-head wins
MAD MUTT'S BBQ has taken the last 17 meetings.
Career comparison
| Pine Tar BBQ | MAD MUTT'S BBQ | |
|---|---|---|
| 48 | Contests | 104 |
| 0 | Grand champs | 6 |
| 2 | Category wins | 17 |
| 2 | Perfect 180s | 4 |
| 96.8% | Best overall (% of perfect) | 98.5% |
| 92.9% | Avg overall (% of perfect) | 94.6% |
| top 58% | Avg finish | top 38% |
| ±1.79% | Consistency (% of perfect) | ±2.02% |
Overall scores show as a share of a perfect total (Master /720, Backyard /360) so the two series compare fairly.
Meat by meat (who finishes ahead when both enter the category)
| Pine Tar BBQ | MAD MUTT'S BBQ | |
|---|---|---|
| 8 | Chicken (25 meetings) | 17 |
| 9 | Pork Ribs (25 meetings) | 16 |
| 8 | Pork (25 meetings) | 17 |
| 3 | Brisket (25 meetings) | 22 |
Common ground
- 🏕️ They've both cooked Smoke in the Spring (OPEN FORMAT) 7 times — MAD MUTT'S BBQ leads there 7–0
- 🏕️ They've both cooked Smoke on the Bricks 5 times — MAD MUTT'S BBQ leads there 4–1
- 🏕️ They've both cooked Shawnee Great Grillers 2 times — MAD MUTT'S BBQ leads there 2–0
- 🏕️ They've both cooked Shawnee Great Grillers State Championship 2 times — MAD MUTT'S BBQ leads there 2–0
- 💥 Biggest beatdown: 41.82 points at Smoke in the Spring (OPEN FORMAT) (2026-04-10)
- 🤏 Closest call: 1.1432 points at Tom Brigham Memorial BBQ (2022-07-29)
Every meeting
| Date | Event | Pine Tar BBQ | MAD MUTT'S BBQ | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-04-10 | Smoke in the Spring (OPEN FORMAT) | 95 / 101 (655.8628) | 14 / 101 (697.6800) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2025-09-26 | Shawnee Great Grillers | 17 / 67 (682.1944) | 4 / 67 (701.7144) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2025-08-08 | Smoke on the Bricks | 22 / 53 (690.7768) | 5 / 53 (701.6800) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2025-04-11 | Smoke in the Spring | 76 / 92 (659.7940) | 18 / 92 (691.9316) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2025-03-21 | 7th Annual Qlathe BBQ Championship | 56 / 70 (659.2452) | 30 / 70 (684.4796) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2024-09-27 | Shawnee Great Grillers | 22 / 73 (675.9544) | 1 / 73 (705.1088) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2024-08-09 | Smoke on the Bricks | 24 / 46 (673.5656) | 19 / 46 (681.0172) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2024-04-05 | Smoke in the Spring | 72 / 97 (667.8744) | 37 / 97 (686.8004) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2023-09-27 | American Royal World Series of Barbecue - Open Contest | 291 / 487 (666.2056) | 61 / 487 (690.2860) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2023-08-25 | Smoke on the Bricks | 25 / 44 (669.5540) | 10 / 44 (686.7772) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2023-04-07 | Smoke in the Spring | 76 / 103 (662.6856) | 26 / 103 (688.4916) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2023-03-17 | 5th Annual Qlathe BBQ Championship | 43 / 68 (673.0168) | 13 / 68 (692.5256) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2022-09-23 | Shawnee Great Grillers State Championship | 13 / 87 (682.1944) | 5 / 87 (698.8116) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2022-08-26 | Smoke on the Bricks | 27 / 48 (666.7200) | 18 / 48 (684.4684) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2022-07-29 | Tom Brigham Memorial BBQ | 10 / 16 (679.3372) | 9 / 16 (680.4804) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2022-04-08 | Smoke in the Spring | 55 / 94 (671.8512) | 31 / 94 (682.7544) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2021-09-24 | Shawnee Great Grillers State Championship (TEAM & JUDGES ARE FULL-WAITLIST ONLY) | 15 / 86 (679.4284) | 1 / 86 (709.1316) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2021-08-20 | Smoke on the Bricks | 10 / 46 (686.2284) | 12 / 46 (683.3256) | Pine Tar BBQ |
| 2021-07-23 | Smokin' Hot Cars & BBQ | 17 / 28 (668.4456) | 4 / 28 (690.2056) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2021-06-04 | Mclouth BBQ Blowout 29th Annual | 5 / 42 (684.0340) | 12 / 42 (677.6568) | Pine Tar BBQ |
| 2021-04-09 | Smoke in the Spring | 54 / 105 (677.0516) | 47 / 105 (679.3484) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2021-03-19 | 3rd Annual Qlathe BBQ Championship | 35 / 70 (669.6688) | 17 / 70 (685.0628) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2020-10-30 | Smoke in the Spring | 80 / 93 (646.1484) | 60 / 93 (667.8744) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2020-03-13 | 2nd Annual Qlathe BBQ Championship | 48 / 68 (655.3484) | 32 / 68 (670.1940) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |
| 2019-06-07 | Smoke Out Hunger BBQ Challenge | 22 / 46 (662.1832) | 19 / 46 (669.0628) | MAD MUTT'S BBQ |